22 Jul 2016

NZ 'wins' nuclear tug-of-war, finally

11:11 am on 22 July 2016

The US is sending a warship to NZ - and it’s being called a win for the nuclear-free movement.

 

No caption

Photo: Unknown

New Zealand will not ask the United States to confirm or deny whether the naval ship being sent here in November will be carrying nuclear weapons, Foreign Affairs Minister Murray McCully says.

But officials will assess whether it complies with New Zealand law.

On Thursday, United States Vice President Joe Biden confirmed during a meeting with Prime Minister John Key in Auckland that America would send a ship to the New Zealand Navy's 75th anniversary celebrations.

The US has not sent a naval ship since 1983, as it refuses to say whether its ships are nuclear-armed, as required by New Zealand's nuclear-free law.

Biden has given no details about the vessel which will be sent in November, including whether it would be carrying weapons.

NZ Foreign Affairs Minister Murray McCully and US Vice President Joe Biden shake hands yesterday during the veep's flying visit.

NZ Foreign Affairs Minister Murray McCully and US Vice President Joe Biden shake hands yesterday during the veep's flying visit. Photo: NZME/Pool

Author and investigative journalist Nicky Hager yesterday told RNZ that if a ship did come it would be a win for the New Zealand public.

"A whole generation of New Zealanders were highly involved, marched in the streets and cared deeply about nuclear-free policy.

"And the United States were extremely bloody-minded about that, they've gone to send a ship that was either nuclear-powered or nuclear-armed from the very beginning and in the end it's been the US government that's changed and not us.

"So yes, all the people involved in it have won."

Security analyst Paul Buchanan from 36th Parallel Assessments said Biden's visit signalled the US accepted New Zealand's nuclear-free policy.

"The Biden visit is clearly a consolation for not getting a state visit from President Obama during the remainder of his term."

"And it clearly signals that the US accepts New Zealand's non-nuclear policy, In fact, it's an issue that quite frankly was resolved in practice many years ago."

McCully said no foreign country was required to make any declaration on nuclear armament.

"There have been some exchanges about the sort of ship that they might send, and no doubt there will be some more.

"We wouldn't expect to see a final decision until a little closer to the time."

McCully would provide advice to Key on whether the visiting ship was thought to carry nuclear weapons.

The US would not be treated any differently than any other country.

"The prime minister has to sign off on that declaration and I have to make sure that the advice he gets gives him that confidence."

"I've done that over 40 times, to [John Key's] satisfaction so far, so I'm comfortable that we can do that again."

Labour's foreign affairs spokesperson David Shearer said New Zealand and America could now move beyond that chapter in their relationship, with their heads held high.

It would be easy to work out whether the ship complied with the law, he said.

"It's publicised whether a ship is nuclear-propelled, so that's very easy to determine. Whether they are nuclear-armed, other than nuclear submarines and aircraft carriers, pretty much the entire US fleet was decommissioned from nuclear weapons some time ago."

The US is one of 30 countries that has been invited to take part in the anniversary celebrations.

- Reporting by RNZ.