21 Dec 2022

Trump tax returns will be made public, US House panel votes

2:55 pm on 21 December 2022
Former US President Donald Trump speaks at the Conservative Political Action Conference 2022 in Orlando, Florida, on 26 February, 2022.

Former US President Donald Trump has fought for years to keep his tax records private. Photo: AFP

By Anthony Zurcher for the BBC

A committee in the US House of Representatives has voted to make public six years of Donald Trump's tax returns.

The move caps a nearly four-year legal battle by Democrats to obtain the documents, which was ultimately decided by the US Supreme Court last month.

US presidents are not required by law to release their tax returns, but for decades they have done so voluntarily.

The former president has fought hard to shield his tax returns.

The US House Ways and Means Committee voted 24-16 today to publish the documents, with all Democrats on the panel in favour and all Republicans opposed.

One of the committee members, Pennsylvania Democrat Brendan Boyle, said afterwards: "This is one of the most important votes I will ever cast as a member of Congress, and I stand by it 100 per cent."

Kevin Brady, the ranking Republican on the committee, said Democrats had just "unleashed a dangerous new political weapon".

"Congress' enemies list is back," said the Texas congressman. "Every American taxpayer who may get on the wrong side of majority in Congress is now at risk."

It is unclear when the public will see the financial documents.

Lloyd Doggett, a Texas Democrat on the panel, told CNN the release of the files could take "a few days" in order to redact personal information such as Social Security numbers.

The returns could offer a first-hand look into Trump's finances, including his assets, sources of income, charitable contributions and liabilities, including the possibility of loans owed to foreign entities.

In 2016, Trump became the first major-party presidential nominee since Richard Nixon in 1972 to decline to publicly release his tax returns while campaigning for office. At the time, he said he would do so after an Internal Revenue Service audit had concluded.

The House Ways and Means Committee had first sought the returns when Democrats took over the lower chamber of Congress in 2019. The committee, citing a federal law allowing it to request special access to individual tax returns, said the information was necessary as a part of a review of federal tax law.

Republican critics, however, have countered that such explanations were merely an excuse to access Trump's financial documents.

The Trump administration refused to co-operate with the committee's request, prompting a drawn-out legal battle that ended when the US Supreme Court, in an unsigned opinion, upheld an appellate court ruling that the Democrats were entitled to the returns.

In 2020, the New York Times obtained leaked copies of 18 years of Trump's tax returns. In a series of articles on the topic, the newspaper reported that the president paid no federal taxes in 10 of those 18 years and only US$750 (NZ$1183) in each of his first two years in the White House.

It also disclosed that the then-president was in a fight with the Internal Revenue Service over the legitimacy of a $72.9m (NZ$115m) tax refund he had claimed and owed more than $400m ($631m) in debt due by 2024.

A representative of Trump's business empire denied the accuracy of the report at the time. Official copies of the former president's tax returns, which are now expected to be released before Republicans take control of Congress on 3 January, should settle the matter.

- BBC

Get the RNZ app

for ad-free news and current affairs