30 Dec 2019

Nauru Chief Justice dismisses interference claim

9:26 am on 30 December 2019

Nauru's chief justice has "categorically and unreservedly denied" that there is any interference from government in the island's judiciary.

Symbol of law and justice in the empty courtroom, law and justice concept, court

Photo: ikiryo/123RF

Filimone Jitoko was been quoted in the Nauru Government Bulletin defending the 'sanctity of the independence' of the judiciary.

Nauru's government and its judicial system have been strongly criticised for the past six years, beginning with the deportation of the resident magistrate and the denial of a visa for the then chief justice.

That prompted New Zealand to withdraw aid support for the Nauru judiciary.

Later a judge's contract was not renewed after the government was critical of what it considered light sentences being handed down.

The government brought in another Australian judge, Geof Muecke, to hear the trial of the group dubbed the 'Nauru 19' but he declared this group could never receive a fair trial in Nauru given the level of government interference.

That led to abuse of Mr Muecke in the Nauru parliament and a promise to have him removed, which promptly happened.

T-shirts worn by family and supporters of the 19 Nauruans who were prosecuted by government for staging a protest outside of parliament in 2015.

T-shirts worn by family and supporters of the 19 Nauruans who were prosecuted by government for staging a protest outside of parliament in 2015. Photo: Nauru 19/ Facebook

Most recently, in the case of the 'Nauru 19', the judge allowed the trial to go ahead despite the defendants not having legal representation.

But in the Bulletin, Chief Justice Jitoko is quoted saying there is not a "single ounce of truth" in the allegations made about the court and independence was the foundation of Nauru's democracy.