10 Jul 2024

US Democrats still divided over defiant Biden's viability

1:39 pm on 10 July 2024
WASHINGTON, DC - JULY 09: U.S. President Joe Biden delivers remarks during the NATO 75th anniversary celebratory event at the Andrew Mellon Auditorium on July 9, 2024 in Washington, DC. NATO leaders convene in Washington this week for its annual summit to discuss future strategies and commitments and mark the 75th anniversary of the alliance’s founding.   Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images/AFP (Photo by Kevin Dietsch / GETTY IMAGES NORTH AMERICA / Getty Images via AFP)

US President Joe Biden delivers remarks during the NATO 75th anniversary celebratory event at the Andrew Mellon Auditorium on 9 July in Washington, DC. Photo: KEVIN DIETSCH / AFP

Democrats in the US Congress remained deeply divided over whether to fall in line behind President Joe Biden's wounded reelection campaign or urge him to step aside because of persistent questions about his health and acuity.

The party's leaders in the US Senate and House, Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries, said little about hours of closed-door talks among Democratic lawmakers, who in any event lack the authority to push the 81-year-old president aside even if they agreed on a course of action.

Biden's halting 27 June debate performance against Republican Donald Trump and low public approval have raised fresh doubts among some Democrats about his ability to win the 5 November election or to keep up with the demands of his gruelling job for another 4-1/2 years.

Representative Mikie Sherrill became the seventh House Democrat to call on Biden publicly to drop out of the race, saying in a statement, "The stakes are too high - and the threat is too real - to stay silent."

Many more have expressed worries that Biden has not done enough in the ensuing days to convince voters that the debate was an aberration, rather than a true reflection of his abilities.

But the president continues to argue that he is best positioned to defeat former President Trump, 78, whom he casts as a singular threat to American democracy.

Senate Majority Leader Schumer brushed off questions about Biden's fitness, saying three times, "I'm with Joe," during a brief exchange with reporters after Senate Democrats met over lunch to discuss the president's campaign.

House Minority Leader Jeffries, whose members huddled behind closed doors for nearly two hours to debate the path forward, told reporters that the meeting gave Democrats the chance to speak in a "candid and comprehensive fashion" and that the discussions would continue throughout the week.

Asked whether House Democrats were on the same page, Representative Steve Cohen replied as he exited the meeting: "We're not even in the same book."

"While President Biden has made clear he feels he is the best candidate to win this election, nothing that has happened over the past twelve days suggests that voters see things the same way," Representative Lori Trahan said in a statement on Tuesday. She said constituents in her Massachusetts district had raised questions about Biden's ability to beat Trump.

A Reuters/Ipsos poll last week found that one in three registered Democratic voters believed that Biden should quit the race, with 59 percent saying he is too old to work in government.

The poll also found that none of his possible replacements fared better in a matchup against Trump. The poll showed Biden and Trump tied at 40 percent each.

US President Joe Biden and former US President and Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump participate in the first presidential debate of the 2024 elections at CNN's studios in Atlanta, Georgia, on 27 June, 2024.

Biden's fortunes have turned since a late June debate with Donald Trump. Photo: AFP / Andrew Caballero-Reynolds

Swing-state shift

While national public opinion polls offer a view of candidates' standing, US presidential elections are decided state by state. The nonpartisan Cook Political Report on Tuesday changed its ratings on three of the most competitive states -- Arizona, Georgia and Nevada -- to "lean Republican" from "toss-up," citing shifting voter views of Biden following the debate.

If Trump wins the White House and Republicans win majorities in both chambers of Congress, he will face few obstacles in pursuit of major policy changes. Democrats already face an uphill battle to protect their 51-49 Senate majority, as they must defend multiple seats in Republican-leaning states.

Republicans hold a 220-213 majority in the House.

Biden delivered a forceful speech to a gathering of NATO leaders in Washington on Tuesday, using the opportunity to demonstrate he can still serve as a global leader, while Vice President Kamala Harris - seen as the most likely candidate to replace Biden if he were to stand down - campaigned in Nevada.

"The one thing we know about Joe Biden is he is a fighter. He is the first to say when you get knocked down, you get back up," Harris told supporters in Las Vegas.

White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre faced another salvo of questions from reporters about Biden's health on Tuesday. In a statement, the White House physician said Biden was not being treated for any neurological condition and had received a clean bill of health at his most recent physical examination in February.

Biden has secured renewed support from several key constituencies, including from members of the Congressional Black Caucus. Black voters make up a crucial component of the party's base.

Some House Democrats expressed frustration that the party was focused on Biden's shortcomings rather than unifying against Trump, who falsely claims that his 2020 loss was the result of fraud and has not committed to accepting this year's results if he loses.

"I think the president has decided that the discussion has come to an end and that he is firm in his commitment to run," Representative Stephen Lynch said of Biden, adding that the dissidents "are gonna have to get on board."

- Reuters