British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak's government is disputing whether messages requested by an investigation into the handling of Covid-19 are within the inquiry's remit Photo: AFP
Britain's government, led by Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, has refused to hand over internal WhatsApp messages requested by a public inquiry into its handling of the Covid-19 pandemic, and has sought a legal challenge against the demand.
The inquiry, ordered by the government itself in 2021 and chaired by a former judge, had given the government a 1500 (UK time) deadline to hand over the documents.
But the Cabinet Office said the Covid-19 inquiry was going beyond its remit and the WhatsApp messages and other records it had requested were "unambiguously irrelevant".
"The Cabinet Office has today sought leave to bring a judicial review," the office responsible for overseeing the operation of government said in a letter to the inquiry after the deadline passed.
"We do so with regret and with an assurance that we will continue to cooperate fully with the inquiry before, during and after the jurisdictional issue in question is determined by the courts."
A judicial review is a legal challenge to the lawfulness of a decision by a public body, including a public inquiry.
Former Prime Minister Boris Johnson had ordered the inquiry to look into the preparedness of the country as well as the public health and economic response after Britain recorded one of the world's highest total number of deaths from Covid-19.
With a national election expected next year, the detailed examination of decision-making could create political headaches for Sunak, who was finance minister during the pandemic.
"These latest smoke and mirror tactics serve only to undermine the Covid inquiry. The public deserve answers," said Angela Rayner, deputy leader of the opposition Labour Party.
A spokesperson for the inquiry said its chair Heather Hallett had received the Cabinet Office's judicial review claim and that it would provide further updates on Tuesday during a preliminary hearing.
On Thursday, a spokesperson for Johnson said pandemic-era messages and notebooks had been handed to the government and urged them to be passed to the inquiry. The government said it had received WhatsApp material from Johnson, but none from before May 2021, owing to security changes on his devices.
'Absurd' demand
Sunak said earlier on Thursday that the government was confident in its position.
"We've been long cooperating with the inquiry," Sunak told reporters on the sidelines of a summit in Moldova, adding it was important to learn the lessons of the pandemic.
Hallett had relied on Section 21 of the Inquiries Act to compel the government to turn over the information, meaning a failure to do so could amount to a criminal offence.
However, lawyers representing the Cabinet Office said in court filings that the inquiry only had the power to compel the production of relevant material, but had asked the government for irrelevant material including two years' worth of WhatsApp messages between Johnson and 40 different individuals.
The Cabinet Office said it had previously told the inquiry that the documents sought included "comments of a personal nature about identified or identifiable individuals which are unrelated to Covid-19 or that individuals' role in connection with the response to it".
It also said the concept of relevance could not cover all government business and policy areas during the two-year period covering the pandemic.
"That would be absurd," the Cabinet Office said. "It would also mean that the Inquiry would be utterly swamped with material of no value to its work."
-Reuters
