Greater transparency over patient death at Middlemore needed, advocates say

4:07 pm on 14 July 2022

The family of a woman who died at Middlemore Hospital have a right to know what happened and what steps are being taken to address the hospital's problems, advocates say.

It will be one month this weekend since the woman's death at the hospital on 16 June.

A healthcare worker from Middlemore Hospital’s emergency department says the number of staff being scratched from rosters daily is a serious concern as it is already under serious pressure due to staffing shortages.

Middlemore Hospital has seen a surge in patients since June as a result of winter respiratory viruses. Photo: LDR / Stephen Forbes

no metadata

In a statement last week, Health NZ (Counties Manukau) interim district director Dr Pete Watson said chief medical officer Dr Andrew Connolly was leading a review of the incident, which had not yet been finalised.

But he refused to answer questions on when the investigation into the patient's death would be completed or when the findings would be released.

The patient first arrived at the emergency department about 1am on 15 June with a severe headache. She was allegedly told it would likely be hours before she could be seen and left.

She returned to the hospital in an ambulance a few hours later after a "massive" brain haemorrhage and died the following day.

Patient Voice Aotearoa chairperson Malcolm Mulholland said a month on, the woman's family deserved some answers.

"It's pretty obvious it's a system failure and that's why the patient lost their life," Mulholland said.

"People have got to have trust in the health system, because if we don't have that what have we got?"

Malcolm Mulholland, Patient Voice Aotearoa chairperson - single use only

Malcolm Mulholland says it is obvious there has been a system failure at Middlemore Hospital. Photo: LDR / Stuff / David Unwin

Mulholland said patient wait times at hospital emergency departments had reached record levels around the country.

People were facing waits to book appointments with their GPs, so were turning up at hospitals to seek treatment, adding to the strain on an overburdened health system.

"Unless there's something done to address the pressure on doctors we will unfortunately see more cases like this."

Shane Reti

Shane Reti Photo: RNZ / Angus Dreaver

National Party health spokesperson Shane Reti said he thought there should have been progress made on the investigation by now.

"There should have at least been some substantial preliminary findings released," he said.

"I think there should have been some action taken on them before the DHB ceased to exist [on 1 July]."

Reti rejected claims by former Counties Manukau DHB chairperson Mark Gosche that a brief statement released late in June constituted the preliminary findings.

"We need to know if the patient was triaged first or were they told about the wait time first? If it was the latter, that's the policy change that needs to happen right now.

"We need to make sure the best procedures are being applied as soon as possible."

Middlemore Hospital has seen a surge in patients as a result of winter respiratory viruses, such as influenza, and the impact of staff having to take time off due to Covid-19.

Both the hospital and Health NZ were approached for comment.

Local Democracy Reporting is a public interest news service supported by RNZ, the News Publishers' Association and NZ On Air.

Get the RNZ app

for ad-free news and current affairs