7 Jul 2023

Seeking Justice

From Mr Lyttle Meets Mr Big, 5:00 am on 7 July 2023
Podcast episode image for the 'Mr Lyttle Meets Mr Big' podcast. A moody black and white landscape photograph of the Whanganui river is mirrored vertically creating a Rorschach like effect with the episode number 'ELEVEN' overlaid in vibrant green.

Photo: RNZ / Ebony Lamb / Jarred Bishop

The story’s twists and turns continue. The defence team appeal, arguing again that the Mr Big sting evidence was unreliable and should not have been used.

This time the Court of Appeal agrees. 

The defence lawyers go back to court to argue that there’s not enough evidence now to convict David.

They win. The judge rules that David cannot be retried. He is free. The case is over.

Where does that leave Mr Big?

Should the law control Mr Big stings better? Is David Lyttle an innocent man tricked into telling a story that then he had to struggle for more than 10 years to escape? Or is he a murderer who crafted a story of innocence that eventually fooled the court?

And should the police use stories like Mr Big to try to get to the truth about a murder?

Photo: Ebony Lamb Photography

Written and presented by Steven Price

Executive Producers Justin Gregory, Katy Gosset & Tim Watkin

Director Duncan Smith

Music Ebony Lamb and Gram Antler

Images by Ebony Lamb. Design by Jarred Bishop

Supported by the Michael and Suzanne and Borrin Foundation and Te Kauhanganui Tatai Ture, Faculty of Law, Victoria University of Wellington

Victoria University of Wellington logo

Photo: Victoria University of Wellington

Borrin Foundation logo

Photo: Borrin Foundation

Get the RNZ app

for easy access to all your favourite programmes

Subscribe to Mr Lyttle Meets Mr Big

Podcast (MP3) Oggcast (Vorbis)